A Decision Made Is Not Always a Decision Settled
Employers need to be decisive, but they also need to recognise when new information materially changes the position.
A Decision Made Is Not Always a Decision Settled
Employment decisions are often made on the information available at a particular point in time.
An employee has failed to attend work. A medical certificate has been provided. A disciplinary response has been received. An employee's Award classification has been established, or an entitlement has been calculated.
The employer considers the information and reaches a decision.
But what happens when further information emerges?
A decision should not be defended simply because it has already been made.
When the facts change
Consider an employee who has been absent without explanation.
The employer may reasonably begin a process to establish whether the employee intends to return to work.
However, if the employee subsequently provides an explanation or medical evidence, that information needs to be considered before any final employment decision.
Similarly, where an employee responds to allegations of misconduct, the employer must genuinely consider the response. A disciplinary process should not be treated as a formality designed to confirm an outcome that has already been decided.
In wage and entitlement matters, additional information about an employee's duties, employment history or applicable industrial instrument may also affect the original assessment.
The important question is whether the new information is material to the decision.
Being open to new information does not mean starting again
Employers are not required to reopen every matter indefinitely simply because an employee disagrees with the outcome.
There is an important distinction between genuinely new evidence and the repetition of information that has already been considered.
Where the information is relevant and could reasonably affect the outcome, the employer should assess it.
Where the information does not change the facts or applicable obligations, the employer may be entitled to maintain its original position.
The key is to be able to explain why.
Keep the decision-making process clear
When new information is received, employers should establish whether it is reliable, relevant and material.
If necessary, make further enquiries.
Consider whether the original decision remains appropriate.
Document the assessment and communicate the outcome clearly.
Where a decision has already taken effect, employers should seek advice before attempting to reverse or vary it, particularly where dismissal, statutory entitlements or legal proceedings are involved.
The practical lesson
A sound employment decision requires more than reaching a conclusion.
It requires a willingness to consider relevant information, including information that may challenge the employer's original view.
Consistency is important, but consistency should never become an excuse for ignoring material facts.
MTA NSW members dealing with disciplinary matters, employee absences, Award classifications or disputed entitlements should contact the Employment Relations Team when significant new information emerges.